I prefer a shorter, chubbier heart but there's no doubt it's a beautiful stone.  The more I look at it the more I like it. 

I like it, even if it is a bit skinny.  So's my sister, and I like her, ok. 

It looks like it has plenty of sparkle and brilliance, it is a pretty darned high white, so if you can pick it up for not too dear, I think it would turn around fairly rapidly.  Being on the Tunky Fart side of the hill, I'd love to see it as a halo ring, or brooch, or necklace.  I think the halo could give it a bit of extra girth and be a sensational piece. 

I voted "maybe."  My decisive nature is coming out. 

I do tend to prefer the chubbier pears, but this one does have a pretty pleasing shape.  I think I would be more inclined to like it as a pendant than in a ring.  If it was in a ring, maybe bezel set like Lynne's heart?  I can't imagine it with side stones for some reason...  maybe my imagination just isn't good enough today.

It's a bit tall for my tastes (I like them like this  , when I like hearts at all) but I agree with Mikla; it'd look great in a necklace.

I think it will looks great in a bezel.  I would like a fatter one in a ring, but for a necklace it is great.